trovato questa speigazione del crollo su ragin' bull
Four things:
1. Navarre has been growing sales at 20-25% for about 7 years, but only became profitable doing that about 3 years ago. As a result, there were huge tax-loss carryforwards that are just now being exhausted. The transition from untaxed earnings to taxed, with resulting adjustment in the EPS estimates, has caught some investors who weren't around for the lean years by surprise.
2. Even though they have managed to acquire three companies quite efficiently in recent years, the recent announcement of intent to acquire Funimation, Ltd., seems to have generated some skepticism in the market. At up to $140 million, this is by far the largest acquisition they've ever attempted, and was to have required issuance of a significant number of additional common shares, viewed by some as dilutive because Navarre has not had the opportunity to explain how they plan to leverage their distribution skills in what is essentially a publishing venture. Most short-term shareholders are not fully aware that Navarre has already been successful in the home-entertainment software publishing sector with their previous acquisitions of Encore and BCI Eclipse. On Tuesday of this week, when they filed to withdraw the registration with the SEC and seek sources of funding other than issuing more equity, it was probably seen as a sign of weakness, even though Navarre has never issued long-term debt and certainly has the fundamental strength and credit-worthiness to do so now.
3. One could justify the speculation that Navarre stock has been under a relentless short attack in this period. A local Minneapolis brokerage, Miller Johnson Steichem Kinnard (MMID is "MJSK") initiated coverage of the stock about two months ago with a "sell" rating and a price target of 10 (when it was still in the high teens.) This is in contrast to the other three analysts covering it, who comprised two "strong buys" and one "hold" with targets of up to 23. Todays February short interest from NASDAQ confirms a large increase in the period:
http://www.nasdaqtrader.com/asp/short_interest_resp.asp?searchby=Detail&IssueID=17177
4. When the company reported 3rd-quarter earnings on 1-26, it was taken as a two-cent "miss" due to the effect of backing out a one-time tax benefit, and the market focused on the 6% negative surprise after positive surprises in the previous quarters of 54, 128, and 71%, respectively. This was despite the year-over-year comparison that EPS was up to 28 cents from 15, or 87%. Balance-sheet "issues" were seen, an increase in AR, cash at only $5000 on 12-31, and increased inventories, and the company was tight-mouthed in the conference call primarily due to the quiet period imposed by their 1-14 S-3 filing for the secondary offering needed to accomplish the Funimation deal, leading to speculation something more was going on than what really is.
To me, a catalyst for the price-drop was unwittingly furnished by the company, when they sought to raise some further cash by invoking a mandatory warrant exercise provision from an earlier acquisition, the theory for which I laid out here:
http://finance.messages.yahoo.com/bbs?.mm=FN&action=m&board=7077803&tid=navr&sid=7077803&mid=133884
All of this together has created a "perfect storm" scenario that in my opinion has led to the mother of all buying opportunities, which I have been pursuing this week and earlier. I see the stock as really worth between 14 and 18 dollars, and I see it likely to be there in months, not years.